One of our discussions last class was whether or not Fledgling would be an appropriate novel to read and teach in high school. Good question. The initial reaction was no, there is no way I would teach this novel in high school. Why? Fledgling is about a young woman vampire who was picked up on the side of the road by an “older” man. It is kind of creepy because the young woman looked like she was 10 years old, however, in vampire years she was about 50 years old. However, my reasoning was not that reason. A little bit further into the book, the younger woman and this man have sexual relations when he does not know that she is older than 10. And other than that, I had no other reasoning. And so then I realized that single reason alone is not even a solid reason not to teach this novel in high school.
High school students are not given enough credit with the type of novels they are “mature” enough to read or to just understand.
This wonderment had me search the banned books list online for high school students. While researching this online, with the novels listed, it explains why they are banned and the court decision and how many times it was challenged. It is sad, to me, because a lot of the reasons as to why some novels are banned is something that the students can use as a learning tool. They can take the information, and the history that is being taught in a novel to understand history and the past of our country. To learn about how ideals were different in the past, how it has changed and why those ideals were like that in the past. And for me, that is one of the reasons why I love literature so much, understanding the history and the time period it was written, to pull all of that information together to create meaning. I was truly disappointed in seeing that To Kill a Mockingbird was on the list of banned books because I was able to read that novel my tenth grade year in high school and that is one of the first novels I truly was able to connect with, dialogue with and create meaning with the history during that time. I do believe it truly is one of the reasons why I want to be an English teacher and fell in love with literature.
To bring this information together, I think that as society we do not give enough credit to high school students to “handle” the novel. There is some “hard” information to understand and issues, however, the teacher may have to address something that is off the mark for just a second, but then just move right along, get back to what the book is actually addressing. Fledgling does have a lot of underlying meaning which might be hard to address everything in a unit plan that is only about a month long but it isn’t impossible, it can happen. This unit plan would have to be very detailed and creative for the students to understand everything going on in the novel, the hard hitting issues that are all underlying in the text.
Well that is enough of that… I enjoyed Fledgling basically and it was one of my favorite novels in the course.
Tuesday, November 13, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment